Answer:
The Age of Discovery saw an increase in ocean travel, which
allowed churches to send representatives to distant lands to
spread Christianity- C.
C. The Age of Discovery saw an increase in ocean travel, which
allowed churches to send representatives to distant lands to
spread Christianity.
2b2t
Read Shakespeare's "Sonnet 73" and answer the question.
That time of year thou mayst in me behold
When yellow leaves, or none, or few do hang
Upon those boughs which shake against the cold,
Bare ruined choirs, where late the sweet birds sang
In me thou sees the twilight of such day
As after sunset fadeth in the west;
Which by and by black night doth take away,
Death's second self that seals up all in rest.
In me thou seest the glowing of such fire
That on the ashes of his youth doth lie,
As the deathbed whereon it must expire,
Consumed with that which it was nourished by.
This thou perceiv'st, which makes thy love more strong,
To love that well, which thou must leave ere long.
The first stanza figuratively connects old age to _____.
spring
summer
fall
winter
Answer:
fall
Explanation:
Where I live, the trees would do that in late fall or very very early winter, but only if it was a mild winter. Real winter strikes hard and all that is left is the branches.
So I'll pick fall.
Answer: Fall
Explanation: The first stanza (that is the first four lines or quatrain connects old age to early Winter. In such quatrain, Shakespeare's sonnet evokes the natural decay of all things through a series of images, all connected to a tree. A tree with yeallow leaves or a few of them is a common image during late Fall while a tree with no leaves at all is mostly seen in Winter. This idea is reinforced by the phrase "shake against the cold," which evokes the arrival of early Winter.
Choose a poem. Use your literary critique skills and apply them to analyzing the poem.
Although I cannot write down a whole analysis,
I think it'd be easier if you picked a poem that already has an analysis that you can understand.
Links to poems with analysis,
https://sites.google.com/site/edickinsonproject1/the-team
"Poetry analysis is examining the independent elements of a poem to under-stand the literary work in its entirety. Analyzing poem line by line al-lows you to break poems down in order to study their structure, form, langu-age, metrical pattern, & theme."
What is literary analysis?The pur-pose of literary analysis is to inter-pret the meaning of a poem & appreciate it on a deep-er level. Poetry in-volves differ-ent elements like language, rhythm, & structure. To-gether, they tell a story & create a complex-ity that is unique to poet-ic verse. Critiquing poet-ry is about under-standing & analyzing a poem.
To know more about poem click below:
brainly.com/question/27230128
#SPJ2
14-Identify the sentence that uses past perfect tense.
A.
Before Mary got home, Sam ate dinner.
B.
By the time Mary got home, Sam had eaten dinner.
C.
When Mary gets home, Sam will eat dinner.
D.
By the time Mary got home, Sam was eating dinner.
Answer:
B. By the time Mary got home, Sam had eaten dinner.
Explanation:
The past perfect tense shows that something happened before another action in the past. This tense is formed with the helping verb had plus the past participle of the main verb. In this case, it is had eaten. (Eaten is the past participle of the verb eat).
what does whites of water, knocked high in the moonlight by his churnking feet, gleamed like thousandsof tiny white stars mean
Whites of water, knocked high in the moonlight by his churnking feet, gleamed like thousands of tiny white stars appears to be a poetic description of someone or something walking in water, causing ripples that reflect the moonlight and create a sparkling effect that resembles stars.
What does the poem mean?The phrase "whites of water" likely refers to the foamy, white tops of the waves or ripples caused by the movement. "Knocked high in the moonlight" suggests that the person or thing causing the disturbance is moving forcefully or energetically, while "churnking feet" may be a misspelling of "churning feet," implying that the movement is rapid and chaotic.
Overall, the phrase seems to be a vivid and imaginative description of a scene involving water, movement, and light.
Learn more about poems from
https://brainly.com/question/8763558
#SPJ1
Which phrase defines “muster” best? to anger someone to collect, gather to smile, laugh to run quickly
Answer:
Gather to smile
Explanation:
"Muster" means gathering and showing.
The phrase which defines muster best is gather to smile. Thus, option 3 is correct.
What is the central theme of the novel?The metaphor of night is frequently used to represent the situations and feelings that Jews face during the Nazis.
His message is one of peace, forgiveness, and dignity for all people. It took him a long time to believe that the forces opposing evil in the world could win.
Therefore, option 3 gather to smile is the best description for the "muster".
Learn more about the Night, here:
https://brainly.com/question/14327306
#SPJ2
When the cat is called "wonderful," what does this mean?
That the cat is wonderful, pleasant
Answer:
The answer is D) the cat knows when people are doing bad things
Explanation:
It's D because in the excerpt it talked about how sly and sneaky the cat was because it was known to be knowing when people were doing bad things.
What is foreshadowed by Mercutio’s statement that tomorrow "you shall find me a grave man”? Mercutio’s death Mercutio’s attitude Mercutio’s revenge Mercutio’s curse
Answer:
Mercutio's death
Explanation:
Foreshadowing is like giving a look into the future and giving you a hint about what is to come
When Mercutio says, "Ask for me tomorrow, and you shall find me a grave man," he is indeed making a pun on the word grave . Hence option A is correct .
What was the meaning of Mercutio’s statement ?Which means both serious and a hole in which a dead body is buried. I think such a pun, usually a comedic device, illuminates his character even further because it comes at a markedly not comedic moment in the play. Mercutio has just been stabbed and knows that he is about to die, and yet, for some reason, he is still making jokes.
All along, it seems that Mercutio has been unable to deal with strong feelings, either in others or in himself. When Romeo is depressed because Rosaline does not return his love, he doesn't want to go to the Capulets' party and have fun because feels as though he has a "soul of lead."He continues to crack jokes.
Learn more about Romeo and juliet here
https://brainly.com/question/2419604
#SPJ6
This passage is from a science fiction story about an alien invasion of earth that was written in 1898 why might this passage have been effective with readers in its time
B. It is b because it is talking about how our species almost wiped out bison and the dodo and we should think about it. I hope this helps
Answer:
The correct answer is A. It reminded them of the colonialist experience.
Explanation:
War of the Worlds was written in 1898 by scifi pioneer writer H.G. Wells. The plots deals with a so called outer space invasion to Earth and the destruction of all mankind.
Wells wrote this novel as a parody to crtiticize British colonialism. The destructive aliens represented the British, and the human beings are just that, human beings.
In the excerpt, we can analyze that there is a "natural process of destruction" that occurs among different groups of beings. Those "superior" vanquish "inferior" ones, so as to justify humankind being exterminated by "more evolved" Martians.
The poet uses the phrases "sinful earth," "outward walls," and "fading mansion" to signify the speaker’s physical body. What message does the use of such figurative language bring out?
Poor soul, the centre of my sinful earth,
[......] these rebel powers that thee array,
Why dost thou pine within and suffer dearth,
Painting thy outward walls so costly gay?
Why so large cost, having so short a lease,
Dost thou upon thy fading mansion spend?
A.
The diseases of the physical body reflect the suffering of the soul.
B.
The sins committed by the speaker have condemned him.
C.
The speaker’s death is a result of his soul’s sinful nature.
D.
The physical body is beautified at the cost of the soul’s neglect.
The correct answer is option D ("The physical body is beautified at the cost of the soul's neglect").
The figurative language in this poem serves to contrast the physical, ephemeral existence of the body in opposition to the transcendent and therefore most important nature of the soul. The author likens the body to a building that the soul inhabits for only a little while in the grand scheme of things. Then he goes on to question the futility of the efforts we make in order to appear beautiful in the outside, at the expense of our actual soul's well being inside of us.
This idea is perhaps best illustrated on the following lines: "Why dost thou pine within and suffer dearth; Painting thy outward walls so costly gay?; Why so large cost, havins so short a lease".
Hope this helps!
Match each sentence to the correct type of diction.
formal
informal
very informal
Stephanie did not want to cook dinner because she was exhausted from work, so she decided to order food from a restaurant.
“I’m beat—too tired to even move. Forget making food,” grumbled Stephanie as she groped for the phone and ordered take-out.
As her method of earning a living had left her fatigued, Stephanie could not find the energy to cook a meal and thus decided to ask a restaurant to deliver her nourishment.
A-informal
B-very informal
C-formal
I hope this helps!!
which statement is an example of a sentence correctly using parallel structure
Answer:
a
Explanation:
Answer:
A. The death penalty should be abolished because it is cruel, because it is expensive, and because it does not deter crime.
Explanation:
A parallel structure is the repetition of a grammatical form within a sentence.
Statement A is the repetition of subordinate clauses of reason introduced by the reason conjunction because:
because it is cruel, because it is expensive, and because it does not deter crime.
Explain the two meanings of this pun:
A burglar at a construction site fell
Into the concrete mixer.
He became a hardened criminal.
Answer:
Good one. Because he went into the concrete he became hardened because concrete does that.
Explanation:
The pun refers to a burglar becoming a 'hardened criminal' both by literally solidifying in concrete and metaphorically as a descriptor of his criminal nature. The double meaning provides humor by connecting a physical change to a figure of speech that describes his criminal behavior.
The pun "A burglar at a construction site fell into the concrete mixer. He became a hardened criminal" has two meanings, creating a form of wordplay that relies on the double sense of 'hardened.' First, the literal meaning implies that the burglar, by falling into the concrete mixer, has physically 'hardened' as concrete solidifies. On the second, metaphorical level, 'hardened criminal' usually refers to someone who is habitually engaged in crime and is no longer susceptible to remorse; it describes the burglar’s presumably repeated illegal activities.
The pun is intended to be humorous, combining a real-life event with a figure of speech to create an amusing outcome that paints a vivid picture. In the literal sense, the burglar becomes 'hardened' by being encased in concrete, while figuratively, he becomes a 'hardened criminal,' suggesting a transformation due to his own unlawful actions.
“The Poetic Interpretation of the Twist” is written in
a)
2nd Person Point of View
b)
3rd Person Limited Point of View
c)
3rd Person Omniscient Point of View
d)
1st Person Point of View
d, first person point of view
Answer: "The Poetic Interpretation of the Twist" is written in d) 1st Person Point of View.
Explanation: The first person point of view consists in a narrator that talks about himself or herself. In other words, when the first person point of view is used, the narrator is telling his/her own story or expressing his/her own thoughts. Moreover, what shows that "The Poetic Interpretation of the Twist" by Cornelius Eady is written in first person point of view is the use of first-person pronouns, such as "I", "my" and "me".
VERY URGENT!!! Rewrite the proposals in the passive voice, making all the necessary changes.
1. Michael moved the boxes out of the way.
2. Who broke this mug?
3. Tom hasn’t cut the grass yet.
4. Sue locked all the doors.
5. George painted the house last week.
1.) The boxes were moved out of the way by Michael.
2.) The mug was broken by who?
3.) The grass hasn’t been cut by Tom yet.
4.) All the doors were locked by Sue.
5.) Last week, the house was painted by George.
The passive voice generates a statement in which the subject is given an action. Passive voice frequently results in ambiguous, less direct, and wordy phrases.
What is the best way to write in the passive voice?The person or thing being acted on is mentioned first, followed by the performer, who is presented with the preposition "by." The passive form of the verb is represented by a version of "to be": in the line above, "was formulated" is in the passive voice, whereas "formulated" is in the active.
Thus the sentences will be changed as:
The boxes were moved out of the way by Michael.The mug was broken by who?The grass hasn’t been cut by Tom yet.All the doors were locked by Sue.Last week, the house was painted by George.For more information about Passive Voice refer to the link:
https://brainly.com/question/85850
Shakespeare's Macbeth, Act V Scene 5
MACBETH. She should have died hereafter;
There would have been a time for such a word.
Tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow
Creeps in this petty pace from day to day
To the last syllable of recorded time;
And all our yesterdays have lighted fools
The way to dusty death. Out, out, brief candle!
Life's but a walking shadow, a poor player
That struts and frets his hour upon the stage
And then is heard no more. It is a tale
Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury,
Signifying nothing.
Which line refers to the meaninglessness of life?
A. "All our yesterdays have lighted fools/ The way to dusty death."
B. "To-morrow, and to-morrow, and to-morrow,/ Creeps in this petty pace from day to day,"
C. "Out, out, brief candle!"
D. "full of sound and fury,/ Signifying nothing."
D. "full of sound and fury,/ Signifying nothing."
Hope this helps!
☆ Dont forget to mark brainliest ☆
Answer:
D
Explanation:
In the excerpt of the tragedy of Macbeth provided,Seyton, an officer attending on Macbeth, informs him of the death of the Queen. Lady Macbeth plays a predominant role in Macbeth's life for it was she who encouraged Macbeth to take the necessary actions to fulfill his fate. The absence of so great a companion forces him to find no meaning nor significance in life. He became Thane of Cawdor and then king, but it might all seem for no reason for his ambition consumed him.
Can someone help please
C, an independent review website.
Answer:
c or b not sure sorry.
Explanation:
Please help!!!
Who created the Greek alphabet and why?
Answer:
Well the Greece made it because they needed their own way of communicating with each other
Explanation:
The Greek alphabet was developed by a Greek with first-hand experience of contemporary Phoenician script. Almost as quickly as it was established in the Greek mainland, it was rapidly re-exported, eastwards to Phrygia, where a similar script was devised. It was also exported westwards with Euboean or West Greek traders, where the Etruscans adapted the Greek alphabet to their own language, which eventually led to the Latin alphabet.
Describe at least one way that mythological creatures have been used as a source of good luck or protection.
Answer:
One good example is Qilin
Explanation:
In the Chinese culture Qilin is a mythical horned creature that symbolizes luck and good omens. Its said to have dragons traces and is able to speak with humans. It's hard to have a precise representation of Qilin since it varies a lot through history.
Answer:
The Chinese dragon.
Explanation:
In their culture they use this creature to represent good luck and it embodies strength and power.
Select the punctuation from the drop-down menu to correctly complete this sentence
the politiction stood in front of the camera and made this statment __ I would like to Announce that I will run in the next election
Answer: " , " That is the correct answer. Hope this helps!
Answer:
The correct answer is ","
Explanation:
According to punctuation rules related to quotations, the most commonly used mark before a quotation is the comma. In this case, the sentence would read as follows:
The politician stood in front of the camera and made this statement, "I would like to announce that I will run in the next election."
Which sentence contains a dangling modifier?
Answer:
The sentence that contains a dangling modifier is C. Dressed in a snowsuit, the cold weather did not bother the child.
Explanation:
A dangling modifier refers to a word or phrase that modifies a word that has not been clearly stated in the sentence. Usually, in English sentences, these modifiers written as participles -like dressed in a snowsuit- add meaning to the subject of the main clause that follows. Whenever the doer of the action expressed in the participle has not been clearly stated or does not match with the subject in the main clause -in this case, the cold weather-, the phrase is said to contain a dangling modifier.
Answer:
Dressed in a snowsuit, the cold weather did not bother the child.
Explanation:
A dangling modifier is a modifier that incorrectly or ambiguously modifies a word or phrase. Modifiers serve to add more information or context to the sentence.
The choices in the problem all have modifiers at the beginning of the sentence. Because of this, we expect that the word after the modifier should be the one that it's modifying.
We can notice that the modifier in the third choice seem to be telling us that the cold weather was dressed in a snowsuit. This is clearly illogical and not what the sentence is implying. This is therefore a dangling modifier.
In terms of a painting, composition refers to_____. 1. color choice 2. imagery 3. organization of the painting's various images on the canvas 4. style
Answer:
3. organization of the painting's various images on the canvas
Explanation:
The composition is the disposition of the elements on the canvas. That's the essence of the art piece usually, that's where the artist express his/her ideas and choses the way to present it to the world.
Color choice is also important, but not as much, unless it's a totally abstract painting.
It's the same thing in photography and in many other art forms.
which of the following is the best definition of a suspense story
a) a story that tells the glory details of violent acts
b) a story that keeps the reader on edge about its outcome
c) a story that tells about the struggle between good and evil
Answer:
B.
Explanation:
How do you verify that the site is credible? (site 1)
Answer: Be sure that the website is by an expert or someone who has a PhD
Explanation: In addition, be sure that you dont go on a website where kids can access and try to answer questions. Make sure it doesnt have incorrect spelling errors. Use a reliable site
Answer:
Author – Information on the internet with a listed author is one indication of a credible site. The fact that the author is willing to stand behind the information presented (and in some cases, include his or her contact information) is a good indication that the information is reliable.
Date – The date of any research information is important, including information found on the Internet. By including a date, the website allows readers to make decisions about whether that information is recent enough for their purposes.
Sources – Credible websites, like books and scholarly articles, should cite the source of the information presented.
Domain – Some domains such as .com, .org, and .net can be purchased and used by any individual. However, the domain .edu is reserved for colleges and universities, while .gov denotes a government website. These two are usually credible sources for information (though occasionally a university will assign a .edu address to each of its students for personal use, in which case use caution when citing). Be careful with the domain .org, because .org is usually used by non-profit organizations which may have an agenda of persuasion rather than education.
Site Design – This can be very subjective, but a well-designed site can be an indication of more reliable information. Good design helps make information more easily accessible.
Writing Style – Poor spelling and grammar are an indication that the site may not be credible. In an effort to make the information presented easy to understand, credible sites watch writing style closely.
Explanation:
Sally had a smile that rivaled that of Mona Lisa. What does this allusion mean?
Allusion is a figure of speech, in which one refers covertly or indirectly to an object or circumstance from an external context. It is left to the audience to make the connection
it could mean that even though she looked like nothing special, her smile brought herself together
In the novel Grendel, Grendel is trapped in a tree. His mother rescues him, and they return to her cave. Which statement best summarized Grendel’s experience in the cave?
A. His mother represents all of nature that surrounds Grendel. She is a life force but he knows that he must find a reason for her behavior.
B. His mother wants to comfort him but her fur smells like the animals that she hunts. This causes him to fear her and reject her affection.
C. His mother tries to shield him but he realizes that she is primitive. She cannot share his reasoning about the lack of meaning in life.
D. His mother is busy trying to survive. She fails to listen when he explains that the men had no good reason to attack him in the tree.
Answer:Tationia Rolon
Explanation:
Its C
The statement which best summarizes Grendel’s experience in the cave is that his mother tries to shield him but he realizes that she is primitive. She cannot share his reasoning about the lack of meaning in life.
What is experience?Experience refers to conscious events in general, more specifically to perceptions, or to the practical knowledge and familiarity that is produced by these processes. Understood as a conscious event in the widest sense, experience involves a subject to which various items are presented. In this sense, seeing a yellow bird on a branch presents the subject with the objects "bird" and "branch", the relation between them and the property "yellow".
Unreal items may be included as well, which happens when experiencing hallucinations or dreams. When understood in a more restricted sense, only sensory consciousness counts as experience. In this sense, experience is usually identified with perception and contrasted with other types of conscious events, like thinking or imagining.
Learn more about experience,here:
https://brainly.com/question/30055326
#SPJ5
Which of the following is the best example of theme statement?
Answer:
It would be A. There are many paths to gaining spiritual wisdom.
There are many paths to gaining spiritual wisdom.
What's an example of a subject announcement?A thematic assertion is an easy yet powerful message an author is making an attempt to convey in their work. for instance: Love is the glue that binds the Universe collectively. There's no such thing as authentic love.
What is a superb thematic assertion?A theme statement is a sentence that reveals the general idea of the content material as it's far written and supplied on paper. An amazing thematic statement is regularly an idea that may be condensed into one sentence or a generalization based on the complete content.
Learn more about the theme statement here https://brainly.com/question/11600913
#SPJ2
1.Is the example a complete sentence, sentence fragment, or run-on sentence?
In the movie , Right to kill , a father terrorizes his family
A.
run-on sentence
B.
complete sentence
C.
sentence fragment
2.Is the example a complete sentence, sentence fragment, or run-on sentence?
After the son could not take it anymore
A.
run-on sentence
B.
complete sentence
C.
sentence fragment
3.Is the example a complete sentence, sentence fragment, or run-on sentence?
Made a plan to kill his father and run away from home
A.
run-on sentence
B.
complete sentence
C.
sentence fragment
4.Is the example a complete sentence, sentence fragment, or run-on sentence?
Justine Bateman in the movie and several costars
A.
complete sentence
B.
run-on sentence
C.
sentence fragment
5.Is the example a complete sentence, sentence fragment, or run-on sentence?
Because of her fear of her father’s abuse
A.
sentence fragment
B.
complete sentence
C.
run-on sentence
6.Is the example a complete sentence, sentence fragment, or run-on sentence?
Evidently, the movie is based upon a true story
A.
sentence fragment
B.
run-on sentence
C.
complete sentence
What I got as Answer:
B.
C.
C.
C.
C.
C.
It goes such as;
B
C
C
C
C
C
looking on the map I searched the Indian ocean east of Africa for Seychelles exact location use approperiate apostrophes
Answer:original answers
Explanation:
Geographically, we may see the continent as one lump of the earth map placed in-between the Atlantic sea on the region and Asian sea on Asia; Southern sea in the lower extreme and the Arabian Peninsula on the North East, and European continent on the Northwest. Beyond this classification, Africa can be seen as the geographic place which harbors the world hitherto largest black competition. Likewise, in the law on which the human Union (AU ) is established, Africa is seen as a continent containing the 53 countries formally recognized by the UN. In whichever way it is set, our significant share here is the intellect of continent which captures this political history and picture which by meaning, locate their position and level of participation in the global concept of democratic governance.
Final answer:
The Seychelles is an archipelago located in the Indian Ocean to the northeast of Madagascar, known for its biodiversity, cultural diversity, and beautiful natural landscapes. These islands are popular tourist destinations, offering activities like snorkeling, diving, and bird-watching. The Seychelles presents a unique blend of various cultural influences and natural beauty.
Explanation:
The Seychelles, a group of islands, are located in the Indian Ocean to the northeast of Madagascar and about 1,600 km east of the mainland of Africa. This archipelago is composed of 115 islands, characterized by their extraordinary biodiversity, unique ecosystems, and vibrant culture. The Seychelles are known for their beautiful beaches, clear blue waters, and diverse marine life, making them a popular destination for tourists seeking natural beauty and tranquility.
Given their location, the Seychelles are strategically positioned near other island nations such as the Comoros, Mauritius, and Madagascar itself. The archipelago enjoys a warm tropical climate year-round, offering a perfect setting for various outdoor activities including snorkeling, diving, and bird-watching. The Indian Ocean surrounding the islands is teeming with coral reefs and exotic fish, contributing to the island's reputation as a paradise for nature enthusiasts.
The history of the Seychelles is as rich as its natural environment, with evidence of French and British colonial influences alongside African, Indian, and Asian cultures. This melding of cultures is evident in the nation's cuisine, architecture, and languages, making the Seychelles a fascinating place to explore both culturally and naturally.
John Dryden's critical essays foreshadow the satire of which eighteenth-century writer?
yeah they’re right ^^^
Final answer:
John Dryden's critical essays and satirical works significantly influenced the satire of Jonathan Swift in the eighteenth century. Dryden's approach to satire paved the way for Swift's renowned works like 'Gulliver's Travels' and 'A Modest Proposal,' highlighting a clear evolution in English literary satire.
Explanation:
John Dryden's critical essays and satirical works laid foundational stones for the satire of the eighteenth century, particularly highlighting the development of satire that influenced writers such as Alexander Pope and Jonathan Swift. Dryden's literary prowess in satire foreshadows the satirical genius of Jonathan Swift, an eighteenth-century writer renowned for his satirical essays and novels that critiqued societal norms, politics, and religion. Swift's works, such as 'Gulliver's Travels' and 'A Modest Proposal,' demonstrate a direct lineage in satirical technique and thematic exploration from Dryden's critical essays, thus showcasing the progression of English literature's satirical tradition into the eighteenth century.
Moreover, Swift's adeptness at blending satire with social commentary provided a template for future satirists to explore various societal issues through a satirical lens, making him a pivotal figure in the satirical literature of his time. This connection between John Dryden and Jonathan Swift illustrates the evolutionary nature of literature, where earlier forms and themes are adapted and expanded upon by subsequent generations of writers.
please help i will be marking brainiest
Read Genesis 44.
What is Joseph doing?
Joseph commanded the steward
In Genesis 44, Joseph tests his brothers by accusing Benjamin of theft and observes their reactions to determine if they have changed.
In Genesis 44, Joseph is **testing** his brothers to see if they have changed since they sold him into slavery. He plants his silver cup in Benjamin's sack and accuses Benjamin of theft. This act is meant to observe whether his brothers would abandon Benjamin just as they abandoned him years earlier.
In addition to this, he also conceals his identity, accuses them of being spies, imprisons them briefly, and eventually reveals himself to them. When Judah offers himself in place of Benjamin, Joseph sees that his brothers have indeed changed. Eventually, Joseph reveals his identity to his brothers, reassures them, and forgives them for their past actions.
Complete Question:
In Genesis 44 – Joseph Tests His Brothers. What is Joseph doing?