In what year did people start to take design as a discipline?

Answers

Answer 1
Design as a discipline predates 1919 by at least a decade.
Answer 2

Answer:1995

Explanation:


Related Questions

What file format is best to give a printer when working with Adobe InDesign?

JPEG
IDML
HTML

I’ll put you as brainliest if you answer any of my questions correctly (: !

Answers

Answer:

While you are able to insert JPEG images in your InDesign layouts, you are unable to professionally edit them. Launch Adobe InDesign and create a new document. Go to "File" and click "Place" to start importing the JPEG image. Use the file browser to select the JPEG file and click "Open."

You're welcome :)

Answer: Most printers would probably prefer a Press Quality PDF (Portable Document Format) version of your design, but they might also accept files in other CMYK-compatible formats, such as high-resolution (minimum 300 dpi) JPEG or TIFF files.

To export your InDesign document, go to File > Export on the main menu and choose Adobe PDF (Print) from the Format drop-down menu in the Export window.

In the Export Adobe PDF window that opens, choose [Press Quality] from the Adobe PDF Preset menu.

You should also make sure to export your print-ready file with the Bleed included. If you’re exporting to a PDF format, you can check the option in the Export window to include a bleed.

You can also choose to include Printer’s Marks in your exported print-ready file, which includes trim and crop marks, center marks, and page information. These can be really useful to the printer when preparing your work for the press.

If your printer has requested the original InDesign, or ‘native’, files, this is because this gives the printer the freedom to re-export the file if they need to make any minor technical adjustments. You will need to Package your InDesign file before you send it.

(I know this is for PDF, but it works with JPEG too :) )

Hope this helps!

Which of the following sources is considered authoritative?

employee testimonials
published journals

Answers

Answer:

Published Journals are considered authoritative.

Explanation:

This is because employee testimonials are opinions that employees have about the organization they work in and why people should work their.

Define these two types of construction: truss and suspension,
What are the benefits of using each type of construction? What do these two types of construction have in common?

Answers

1. Define these two types of construction: truss and suspension.

A "truss" is a type of structure that is being used when building infrastructures (mainly the roof). In this type of structure, force is mainly applied to only two points. Thus, the term "two-force members" that constitutes the structure.

A "suspension" is a type of structure that is also being used particularly in making bridges (Suspension bridges). They can also be used in making large-span roofs in industrial buildings.

2. What are the benefits of using each type of construction?

The main benefit of using "truss" is that load is applied only on the two joints. This makes it physically stronger, easier to install and cost-effective. Suspension structure, on the other hand, allows the transmission of loads to the ground. This is made possible with the help of a number of cables.

3. What do these two types of construction have in common?

Both of the "truss" and "suspension" are cost-effective for they only need a few amount of supplies. Both of them carry loads by distributing them to other places. The weight of a roof in a "truss" is being distributed to the other walls while the weight of the roof in a "suspension" is being distributed to cable going down the ground.

A truss refers to a structure that is made up of one or more triangular units that are connected by long beams at the joints.

It should be noted that the triangles of a truss structure are vital to keep the structure from collapsing and sheering.

A suspension refers to a type of bridge where the main load-bearing elements are hung from the suspension cables. It should be noted that the load is distributed to the cables.

In conclusion, the types of construction are typically used in bridge building.

Read related link on:

https://brainly.com/question/19538080

In the film Casablanca, the filmmaker uses a flashback to show Rick and Ilsa in Paris (starting at 38:50). If you were staging the play, would you include a flashback like this? Why or why not?

Answers

Final answer:

Including a flashback sequence in a stage adaptation of Casablanca can be an effective tool for providing backstory and character development, though its execution depends on the theatre's technical capabilities and the director's vision. Creative stagecraft may be necessary to deliver this narrative technique convincingly.

Explanation:

When staging the play Casablanca, which was directed by Michael Curtiz, Warner Brothers, in 1942, including a flashback scene like the one showing Rick and Ilsa in Paris would provide a critical narrative function. Flashbacks can offer valuable backstory and character development, which can deepen the audience's understanding of the relationship dynamic and the emotional stakes at hand. In this instance, the flashback is essential because it explains the complexity and history of the central relationship, which is pivotal to the plot. If a live play were to maintain this flashback, it could be carried out with creative stage effects, lighting, or set design to differentiate the past from the present.

However, the nature of film versus theatre is an important consideration. Theatre must deal with the limitations of a static stage and a live audience, potentially making such shifts in time and setting more challenging to portray convincingly. Yet, these transitions are opportunities for imaginative stagecraft and can be deeply engaging if done well. Reflecting on the ideas shared by Hal Luftig regarding Kinky Boots, the use of clear metaphors or parallel actions on stage can compensate for the lack of filmic effects in transitioning scenes or suggesting flashbacks.

Ultimately, whether to include a flashback would depend on the director's vision and the creative capacity of the theatre to handle such a shift without confusing the audience. It might also be influenced by whether the director believes, similar to Marshall's take on Rear Window, that the play transcends plot devices and relies on other theatrical elements to convey its message.

1. replaced the harpsichord as the main keyboard instrument of the classical era
A. opera
2. the instrumental group that accompanies an opera
B. classical
3. a large musical work, usually written in four movements
C. string quartet
4. a musical play in which the lines are sung, not spoken
D. symphony
5. a musical ensemble made up of two violins, a viola, and a cello
E. orchestra
6. solos heard within an opera
F. piano
7. the period of music from 1750 - 1825
G. dynamics
8. crescendo and decrescendo are examples of these
H. aria and recitative

Answers

Answer:

c

Explanation:

Character pieces are by definition

A. based on real people.
B. funny.
C. short.
D. complicated.

Answers

D .complicated hope this helped

Answer:

C

Explanation:

Look at Pieter Bruegel the Elder's Peasant Dance,

This was painted during the Reformation. What was Bruegel trying to

communicate?

Answers

Answer:

The terror and violence of religious conflict are always nearby

Explanation:

Final answer:

Pieter Bruegel the Elder's painting, Peasant Dance, communicates a message of unity and social harmony among peasants during the Reformation.

Explanation:

Pieter Bruegel the Elder's painting, Peasant Dance, was created during the Reformation. In this painting, Bruegel was trying to communicate the idea of unity and social harmony among peasants during a time of religious upheaval. He depicted the peasants engaging in a joyful dance, wearing bright and colorful clothing, symbolizing their shared humanity and celebration of life, regardless of their religious differences. Bruegel's intention was to promote a message of tolerance and acceptance during a period of religious tension.

Learn more about Reformation here:

https://brainly.com/question/18010893

#SPJ3

Brainliest and 20 points :)
What do El Greco, Claude Monet, and Vincent van Gogh have in common?

They are all famous for photography.
They began their careers as performing artists.
They experienced rejection during their careers.
They are all famous painters from North America.

Answers

I believe the answer is they experience rejection during their careers.
Final answer:

El Greco, Claude Monet, and Vincent van Gogh have in common that they experienced rejection during their careers. Option C is correct.

Explanation:

El Greco, the Spanish painter, faced criticism for his unconventional style and was not widely appreciated during his lifetime. Monet, the French Impressionist painter, struggled to gain recognition for his work and faced financial challenges. Van Gogh, the Dutch post-impressionist painter, was rejected by the art establishment and faced mental health issues.

Despite the rejection, all three artists went on to become influential figures in art history and their works are highly regarded today.

Learn more about Rejection in Art Careers here:

https://brainly.com/question/32106130

#SPJ3

Problems that caused poor sound quality in early films

Answers

Answer:

Old movies (pre-1950) were made using optical sound recording, which had very little dynamic range.

Answer:The acoustics of the early films was greatly poor because of the inherent archaic sound devices available to them during this period. However, the energy put into the productions of this period was also part of the adverse effects on the sound productions.

Explanation: In a nutshell, it is obvious that many of the devices available for sound productions at this time was purely analog which has little or no points of editing.

When delivering a final project to a client, what is important to include?

Select all that apply.

A)previous versions
B)native files
C)RAW photos
D) linked images

Answers

When delivering a final project, include the native files and any linked images used in the final version. It is generally not required to provide previous versions or RAW photos unless asked. Export digital images in a high-quality format like TIFF for archival projects. C is correct.

When delivering a final project to a client, it is essential to include certain key elements that ensure the client has everything they need for future use and reference. It is not typically necessary to deliver previous versions of the work unless specifically requested, as the client is usually most interested in the finalized version. Including the native files is critical, as it allows the client to make future edits or alterations to the original design files. While you may not need to provide RAW photos if they were used during the project, you must include any linked images or assets that are part of the final design to prevent issues with missing graphics or links in the files.

Different projects may have different requirements for the output format of the final deliverables. When developing and exporting digital images for a project such as the Enhanced Archival Photography (EAP) project mentioned, the RAW files are not overwritten but are exported as TIFF files to provide a high-quality output format that is suitable for archival purposes.

Do you think combining food and art is a good idea? Why or why not?

Answers

Answer:

Yes because the preparer has some sort of connection to the food when they are preparing it and thats is why food can be considered as art.

Yes because you are eating a literal masterpiece






i love food

What are the consequences of breaking intellectual property law?

Select all that apply.

having to pay a fine
having to remove the artwork
possible imprisonment
losing the right to publish any artwork

Answers

Answer: I select. having to pay a fine and possible imprisonment.

Explanation: They can result in consequences such as: Criminal fines. Imprisonment for several years, depending on the nature of the charges..

Which of these words is an antonym of variations?

A.
deviations
B.
adaptations
C.
similarities
D.
modification

Answers

Answer:

C.) Similarities

Explanation:

C: similarities... would be the answer to your question :)

Which of the following DOES NOT describe musical life during the Classical
era?
A. Concerts were unusually long by today's standards.
O
B. There were more public concerts than in the Baroque era.
C. Most concerts were for the nobility only.
D. Many middle-class homes had instruments, especially the piano.

Answers

The statement that does not describe musical life during the classical era is most concerts were for the nobility only.

What do you mean by the Classical era?

The classical period refers to the period of classical music between 1730 to 1820.

The increase in public performance gave new composers to venues that perform their works. Also, Heavy ornamentation is not the characteristic of classical-era music.

Therefore, concerts for nobility only do not describe the musical life during the classical era.

Learn more about the Classical Era here:

https://brainly.com/question/861180

Answer: C

Explanation: I got it wrong and it told me the answer

Answer the following question in 3-4 complete sentences.

An abstract painting. The top two thirds of the image contain squares of different colors and textures, several of which are vertical. The bottom third contains a painting of an eagle that is centered on the page.
Has the artist in the piece above entitled, Canyon, used all seven principles of design? Give one example used by the artist in this piece for each of the following principles: balance, harmony, proportion, and movement.




Answers

In abstract painting, the utilization of harmony in the colors produces an almost harmonious effect when seeing each hue or form. It's indeed since they worked well together and everything looked correct when they employed balance.

The reason proportion is utilized is that every form occupies a specific amount of space, never more than that of another shape. Moreover, movement is employed because, in addition to the brushstroke movement, each form may have a distinct appearance.

For example, by arranging the squares such that they are evenly spaced throughout the upper two-thirds of the picture, the artist employed balance. Throughout the painting, the artist employed harmony by sticking to a palette of hues and textures.

Therefore, When each hue or form was seen, the use of color harmony created an almost harmonic appearance.

Learn more about abstract painting here,

https://brainly.com/question/9867087

#SPJ3

Which of the following best describes Rhapsody in Blue? A. Piano concerto B. Jazz rock C. String quartet D. Fuging tune

Answers

Answer: your answer is b or c

Explanation:

It is Jazz-rock, which describes best the Rhapsody in Blue. Thus, Option B is correct.

What is Rhapsody?

The term Rhapsody is known as a portion that is of an epic poem that is adapted for rectification. It is also stated as a highly emotional utterance or a literary work. For better understanding, an example will be taken.

An emotional musical piece which is composed by George Gershwin, named "Rhapsody in Blue”.  It is an artist who expressed enthusiastic praise from an ardent fan. It is the rhapsody, in which any of the ecstatic or extravagantly enthusiastic utterance of speech or writing can be seen.

Some of the synonyms are ecstasy, rapture, and swoon. The term rhapsody is a word of the noun. Basically, Rhapsody is a feeling that is effusively enthusiastic or ecstatic expression.

Thus, Option B is correct.

Learn more about Rhapsody from here:

https://brainly.com/question/1383736

#SPJ6

what do roger fry and Clement Greenberg have in common​

Answers

Answer:

They both endorsed artist who were being overlooked or mocked at the time and helped make them famous later on.

Explanation:

They did not believe that art could be measured by moral criteria but that it should be evaluated according to the beauty of the form and lines


In sculpture, what is modeling? Name two benefits to this technique of sculpture

Answers

Answer:

Modeling is essentially a building-up process, you add more of the material to build up the sculpture. Modeling is easy and inexpensive.

--------------

Hope that helps :)

Modeling, also spelled modelling, in sculpture, working of plastic materials by hand to build up form. One is people use it as a therapy thing instead of having a therapy dog they therapy art. Another is it’s helps you get a head start in life.

Mnemonic devices set to music prove the power of ____ response to music.

Intellectual

Emotional

Long-term

Physical

Answers

Answer:

I think the answer is Long-term.

I hope this helps!  Sorry if I'm wrong!

27 POINTS
Which of the following is NOT considered a Fine Art? Explain.
A. Painting
B. Printmaking
C. Design
D. Sculpture

Answers

Answer:

Fine Art is rooted in drawing and design-based works such as painting, printmaking, and sculpture. Other non-design-based activities regard as fine arts, include photography and architecture.

I believe the answer is C ( if I’m wrong sorry!)

what effect does Dali's visual illusion in Swans Reflecting Elephants have on the viewer?

Answers

Answer:Swans Reflecting Elephants (1937) is from Dali's Paranoiac-critical period. Painted using oil on canvas, it contains one of Dali's famous double images. The double images were a major part of Dali's "paranoia-critical method," which he put forward in his 1935 essay "The Conquest of the Irrational." He explained his process as a "spontaneous method of irrational understanding based upon the interpretative critical association of delirious phenomena." Dali used this method to bring forth the hallucinatory forms, double images and visual illusions that filled his paintings during the Thirties.

As with earlier Metamorphosis of Narcissus, Swans Reflecting Elephants uses the reflection in a lake to create the double image seen in the painting. In Metamorphosis, the reflection of Narcissus is used to mirror the shape of the hand on the right of the picture. Here, the three swans in front of bleak, leafless trees are reflected in the lake so that the swans' heads become the elephants' heads and the trees become the bodies of the elephants. In the background of the painting is a Catalonian landscape depicted in fiery fall colors, the brushwork creating swirls in the cliffs that surround the lake, to contrast with the stillness of the water.

Explanation: WEB

What are the three main principles of Greek

Answers

Answer:  balance,color,rhythm.

Explanation:

If you are talking about greek aesthetics, this is your answer

Balance/color/rhythm

What are the three types of immortality? How does Kundera define each?​

Answers

Answer:

Type 1: Immortality through longevity

Type 2: Spiritual immortality

Type 3: Immortality through regeneration

Immortality," the author's persona to the ceiling of the concert hall and jostle each other in unbelievable congestion."

At what building can the image below be found?

Answers

This image can be found in the Amiens Cathedral.

Answer:

Explanation:

Amiens Cathedral.

Which two sentences from this product review best support the author's point of view on the most important quality of a vacuum cleaner?
A) The following is our unbiased opinion of these top cordless vacuum brands.
B) The Dirt contains a large container to store dirt and makes very little noise.
C) This cleaning capability is what makes the Dirt the best of the three.
D) It does have the largest container to store dirt.
E) Even these positives cannot take away its deficiencies in picking up dirt.

Answers

the answer to this question is B, E
Final answer:

Sentences B and E from the product review best support the author's viewpoint on a vacuum cleaner's important qualities, focusing on the size of the dirt container and the effectiveness in picking up dirt.

Explanation:

From the product review provided, the two sentences that best support the author's point of view on the most important quality of a vacuum cleaner are:

B) The Dirt contains a large container to store dirt and makes very little noise.E) Even these positives cannot take away its deficiencies in picking up dirt.

These sentences highlight two critical aspects: the size of the container and the actual performance in picking up dirt. Sentence B emphasizes capacity and noise level, which can be positives, while sentence E underscores the fundamental purpose of a vacuum cleaner, which is its efficacy in cleaning. Therefore, the mention of positives and deficiencies directly reflects on what the author considers critical in a good vacuum cleaner.

Which artwork is an example of an assemblage?

Sorry I don't know how to submit the pictures ;(

Answers

Answer:

i dont know how to help i need to see the picture

Explanation:

Which of these musicians was responsible for pioneering multiple forms of jazz? Joe Zawinul

John Coltrane

Miles Davis

Scott Joplin

Answers

Miles Davis was responsible for pioneering multiple forms of jazz. The right answer is c.

Jazz was invented in many different ways by Miles Davis, who had a lasting impact on the development of the music. Davis consistently pushed the limits of jazz norms, from his early work in bebop to his crucial role in the creation of modal jazz, cool jazz, and fusion.

His innovative approaches to improvisation, collaboration with other talented musicians, and willingness to embrace new sounds and technologies made him a transformative figure in shaping the diverse landscape of jazz music. Miles Davis's groundbreaking contributions spanned various jazz styles, cementing his legacy as a true pioneer of the genre.

The correct answer is option c.

Know more about jazz here

https://brainly.com/question/34285430

#SPJ2

Final answer:

Miles Davis is the musician among the options given who pioneered multiple forms of jazz, including bebop, cool jazz, modal jazz, and jazz fusion, significantly influencing the genre's evolution.

Explanation:

The musician responsible for pioneering multiple forms of jazz among Joe Zawinul, John Coltrane, Miles Davis, and Scott Joplin is Miles Davis. Davis was instrumental in the development of several pivotal jazz movements, including bebop, cool jazz, modal jazz, and jazz fusion. Starting his career in the bebop era alongside giants like Charlie Parker, Davis soon ventured into cool jazz with albums like The Birth of the Cool. His exploration of modal jazz is epitomized in the iconic album Kind of Blue, which remains one of the best-selling jazz albums of all time. Furthermore, Davis's involvement in the creation of jazz fusion in the late 1960s and early 1970s, particularly through albums like In A Silent Way and Brew, marked a significant blend of jazz with electronic music and rock.

name the actor of brain oconner in fast and furious

Answers

Answer:

Paul Walker

Explanation:

Answer:

Brian O'Conner is a fictional character and one of the main protagonists of The Fast and the Furious franchise. He is portrayed by Paul Walker and first appeared on film, alongside fellow protagonist Dominic Toretto, in The Fast and the Furious (2001).

At the end of a project, what files should be kept for archiving?

Select all that apply.

A)edited images
B)client copy
C)RAW photos
D) native files

Answers

Answer:

A

Explanation:

Answer:

native files and edited images.

Explanation:

trust



Which sentence quotes a research source correctly?

A) Although most scientists agree on the amount of funding needed for the experiMent, a few "wildly and vehemently disagree"

B) Although most scientists agree on the amount of funding needed for the experiment, a few "wildly and vehemently disagree." (74).

C) Although most scientists agree on the amount of funding needed for the experiment, a few "wildly and vehemently disagree" (Radel)

D) Although most scientists agree on the amount of funding needed for the experiment, a few "wildly and vehemently disagree" (Radel, page 74).

Answers

D. As you should quote the author and their page number in most cases.
Other Questions
please this is urgent pleas help 50 points!! Fred Rodriguez and Alma Morton are running for an open U.S. Senate seat. During a debate, they had this exchange: "I believe that people should take responsibility for their actions," Fred said. "If they are going to hurt others then they should pay for their actions. Unsupervised children are to blame for many crimes. Their parents should be held accountable." "Many parents in our community work full time," Alma replied. "They don't have enough income to pay a child-care provider. And now you're suggesting that they should be arrested for crimes their children commit? How are they supposed to feed their families if they are in jail? Shame on you for suggesting such a thing! I support the Families Now tax that provides funds for child services." "The last thing we need is another tax," Fred said. "Local nonprofit agencies should help children instead." Which candidates statement implies he or she has sympathy for the problems of working families and would tend to support their platform? Alma: Shame on you for suggesting such a thing!" Alma: They don't have enough income to pay a child-care provider. Fred: "I believe that people should take responsibility for their actions." Fred: "Local nonprofit agencies should help children instead." What is the major difference in focus between a location decision in the service sector vs. The manufacturing sector? \What is the authors purpose in including paragraphs 2-6 The sum of four times a first number and a second number is 68. If the first number is decreased by twice the second number the result is -1. Find the numbers. 10) Suppose you have a transparent material that is more dense than glass. How would the light ray beaffected? Y There are two important isotopes of uranium, 235U and 238U; these isotopes are nearly identical chemically but have different atomic masses. Only 235U is very useful in nuclear reactors. Separating the isotopes is called uranium enrichment (and is often in the news as of this writing, because of concerns that some countries are enriching uranium with the goal of making nuclear weapons.) One of the techniques for enrichment, gas diffusion, is based on the different molecular speeds of uranium hexafluoride gas, UF6 . (a) The molar masses of 235U and 238UF6 are 349.0 g/mol and 352.0 g/mol, respectively. What is the ratio of their typical speeds vrms ? (b) At what temperature would their typical speeds differ by 1.00 m/s? (c) Do your answers in this problem imply that this technique may be difficult? An earthen trapezoidal channel (n = 0.025) has a bottom width of 5.0 m, side slopes of 1.5 horizontal: 1 vertical and a uniform flow depth of 1.10 m. In an economic study to remedy excessive seepage from the canal two proposals, (a) to line the sides only and, (b) to line the bed only are considered. If the lining is of smooth concrete (n = 0.012), calculate the equivalent roughness in the above two cases for a bottom slope of 0.005 Use synthetic substitution to find f(2) and f(3).1.f(x) = 3x^4 - 12x^3 - 12x^2 + 30x2. Write the polynomial equation of degree 4 with leading coefficient 1 that has roots at -2, -1, 3, and 4. What is the mass of an object that has a density of 1.3 g/cm3 and a volumeof 2 cm3? (The density of an object has the equation d =m/v.)OO A. 1.5 gO B. 3.39O C. 0.7gO D. 2.6gO Suppose you move along a wire at the same speed as the drift speed of the electrons in the wire. Do you now measure a magnetic field of zero? Biphenyl, C 12 H 10 , C12H10, is a nonvolatile, nonionizing solute that is soluble in benzene, C 6 H 6 . C6H6. At 25 C, 25 C, the vapor pressure of pure benzene is 100.84 Torr. What is the vapor pressure of a solution made from dissolving 10.3 g 10.3 g of biphenyl in 27.8 g 27.8 g of benzene? Which is the best step to do next to solve the equation bycompleting the square?The first few steps in solving the quadratic equation 5x2 +27x = 14 - 13x by completing the square are shown.5x2 + 27x = 14 - 13x5x2 + 40x = 145(x2 + 8x) = 145(x2 + 8x + 16) = 305(x2 + 8x + 16) = 945(x2 + 8x + 4) = 185(x2 + 8x + 4) = 34 Someone help me with this question. Thx when water droplets in clouds become heavy, they fall to earth as _______ ?A - evaporation B - condensation C - permafrostD - precipitation Zinc, an essential trace element for most organisms, is present in the active site of the enzyme carboxypeptidase. The zinc most likely functions as a(n) A) competitive inhibitor of the enzyme. B) noncompetitive inhibitor of the enzyme. C) allosteric activator of the enzyme. D) cofactor necessary for enzyme activity. E) coenzyme derived from a vitamin. Read the excerpt from Take the Tortillas Out of Your Poetry.My friend had concluded that if he took his language and culture out of his poetry, he stood a better chance of receiving a fellowship. He took out his native language, the poetic patois of our reality, the rich mixture of Spanish, English, pachuco and street talk which we know so well. In other words, he took the tortillas out of his poetry, which is to say he took the soul out of his poetry.Which best explains how Anayas word choice establishes his voice in the excerpt?Anaya compares tortillas to the soul of a Mexican-American writer, demonstrating the ability of these writers to combine Spanish and English in their writing.Anaya compares tortillas to the soul of a Mexican-American writer, emphasizing his belief that writers must be allowed to express their culture and heritage.Anaya compares tortillas to the soul of a Mexican-American writer to persuade people to read more literature by writers that come from mixed heritages and diverse cultures.Anaya compares tortillas to the soul of a Mexican-American writer to express his opinion that only those writers who exist outside of the mainstream are worthy of an audience. how many aluminum atoms are in 3.78g of aluminum? . A 10-ft ladder is leaning against a wall. If the top of the ladder slides down the wall at a rate of 2 ft/sec, how fast is the bottom moving along the ground when the bottom of the ladder is 5 ft from the wall Select the expression that represents the following statement: 52 minus 4 times the difference of 13 and 7. What were Punnett squares developed to do?to predict the probability of offspring phenotypesto predict the probability of offspring genotypesneither of the above